Deciding for 011 - Metapod

Metapod, the cocoon Pokémon. A pretty accurate and all-encompassing description.

Type: Bug

Previous evolution: Caterpie

Evolution: Butterfree

Pokedex color: Green

This discussion will end on December 24th, 2015. We'll take a break after this one, and resume sometime after New Years.

Deciding for 010 - Caterpie

Caterpie, the first listed bug type. Does he deserve to be in the True Pokedex?

Type: Bug

Evolution: Metapod

Pokedex color: Green

This discussion will end on the 21st of November, 2015, at midnight. Extended to December 1st.

Caterpie was added to the True Pokedex.

Deciding for 009 - Blastoise

After this we have Caterpie, the first Pokémon for whom there is really something to discuss.

Type: Water

Previous evolution: Wartortle

Pokedex color: Blue

This discussion will end on November 11, 2015, midnight.

Blastoise was added to the True Pokedex.

Deciding for 008 - Wartortle

Type: Water

Previous evolution: Squirtle

Evolution: Bastoise

Pokedex color: Blue

This discussion will be closed November 7th, 2015, midnight.

Wartortle was added to the True Pokedex.
There was only one opinion given, so if anyone would like to reopen discussion, comment.

Deciding for 007 - Squirtle

After this line, we're on the Caterpie, who there might actually be discussion about.

Type: Water

Evolution: Wartortle

Pokedex color: Blue

Discussion will be closed November 4th, 2015, at midnight.

Squirtle was added to the True Pokedex.
There was only one opinion given, so if anyone would like to reopen discussion, comment.

Deciding for 006 - Charizard

     From now on, I will be putting my thoughts about the Pokémon in question in the comments, and using the main post for more factual stuff.

Primary Type: Fire

Secondary Type: Flying

Previous evolution: Charmeleon

Pokedex color: Red

Discussion will be closed on the 30th of October, 2015, midnight. We're taking a break during Halloween.

Charizard was added to the True Pokedex.
There was only one opinion given, so if anyone would like to reopen discussion, comment.

Deciding for 005 - Charmeleon

     Though the least recognized of his evolutionary chain, I find that I really like Charmeleon. And I sincerely doubt I need to worry about him getting booted.

     Name: Good. Personally, I like his name. One could argue that it is too close to Charmander, and that this line needs more name changing, but I think it works well.

     Appearance: Very good. He has simple signs of progression, such as being larger, having more defined and longer limbs, and having a larger flame on his tail, as well as having eyes more similar to Charizard. I'm very fond of the one horn that he has, which will split into two in his next evolution.

This discussion will end on October 29th, 2015 at midnight.

Charmeleon was added to the True Pokedex.
There was only one opinion given, so if anyone would like to reopen discussion, comment.